I can be honest and say that I'm not fond of pick-up dresses at ALL, they just looked wrinkled and messy to me. But I LOVE the bodice/neckline of that one - and it looks nice on you. Very complimentary.
The one thing I wanted with my dress was a cathedral train. So that's what I got. Everything else I just kind of flowed with, since I originally wanted a strapless dress.
Together, with dress ($850), alterations, and accessories, I'd gather that mine was about... $1350. From what everyone's rices are like here, I'd say you did wonderful!!